Public posting of marks

My university has a policy where the marks for each assessment task are posted – anonymously – on the departmental notice board. I think it goes back to a time when students were not automatically notified by email and individual notifications of grades would have been too time consuming. Now that our students get their marks as soon as they are captured in the system, I asked myself why we still bother to post the marks publicly.

I can’t think of a single reason why we should. What is the benefit of posting a list of marks where students are ranked against how others performed in the assessment? It has no value – as far as I can tell – for learning. No value for self-esteem (unless you’re performing in the higher percentile). No value for the institution or teacher. So why do we still do it?

I conducted a short poll among my final year ethics students asking them if they wanted me to continue posting their marks in public. See below for their responses.

selection_001

Moving forward, I will no longer post my students marks in public nor will I publish class averages, unless specifically requested to do so. If I’m going to say that I’m assessing students against a set of criteria rather than against each other, I need to have my practice mirror this. How are students supposed to develop empathy when we constantly remind them that they’re in competition with each other?